Essays 3 min read

Not All Technology Is Digital

Not All Technology Is Digital
Source

Technology usually refers to devices. Screens, models, software, the things that need charging. That definition is too narrow to be useful, and it hides most of what a practice is actually made of.

A better one: technology is anything that has left the body. A word is technology. So is a method, a price, a template, a schedule, a brand. The moment something can be written down, handed to someone else, and repeated without you in the room, it becomes a tool. It no longer depends on your being there to work.

Anything that gets structured, shared, passed around, or paid for has to go through this step. A thought that stays inside you cannot be sold, taught, or built on. The disembodied version makes a practice legible to other people, and legibility makes a practice survive. The point is only to see the line clearly, so that the tools stay in service of the person using them rather than the other way around.

I wrote two years ago that technology does not change habits of mind; it amplifies them. If that holds, then the first job is to know which parts of your work are already technology, because those are the parts that will be amplified, for better or worse, by whatever comes next.

A short inventory

Once you look for it, the non-digital technology in a creative practice is everywhere.

Language is the oldest one. A brief, a prompt, an articulation of what you do: these are all ways of packaging a thought so that someone else, or something else, can act on it. Writing a prompt for a person or a brief for a machine is the complete opposite.

Marketing is technology. Perceived value is a protocol for making a stranger want something they haven't experienced yet. A price compresses judgment into a number that can travel. Branding, positioning, the whole apparatus of being found: none of it is you, and all of it is necessary.

Money is technology. Invoices, subscriptions, retainers, the mechanics of being paid for work that is hard to point at. Finding money is a learnable skill precisely because it sits outside the work itself.

Automation of communication is technology and the self-accountability underneath it. Newsletters, scheduled posts, templates, the repeatable parts of talking to people. The question is not about whether to repeat (/automate), but which parts of your communication you refuse to.

Complexity and systems thinking are technologies for reading structures you did not design and cannot control. Typography, branded world-building and bio design, the electives that ran at CBS this year, were always on this side of the line. Aesthetics sits here too, in a particular way: taste is embodied, but a style guide is a tool. The gap between those two things is where most of the interesting AI work is happening right now.

And AI itself, placed last on purpose. Digital technology is one instance of the category. It is not the category.

What is Not Technology

What is left after the inventory is smaller than it looks, and more important. Self-knowledge. The capacity to hold space for someone else. The time spent working out what you think before you say it. The practice of noticing what no one is asking for. These cannot be handed over. They work only when you do them.

A simple test: if it still works when someone else does it, it is technology. If it only works when you do it, it is leadership.

Critical Business School 2027

Starting in January, Critical Business School runs on this distinction. Monday is for leadership: the core course on the self, transformation, and the work you cannot delegate. Thursday is for technology: electives and masterclasses, where we communicate value to complexity and AI. Self-work without technology never meets others. Technology without a self has nothing to amplify.

CBS 2027 starts January 4 at SOFTlab, on Mondays and Thursdays, 1:00 to 2:30 PM. It is limited to ten people. The program is $500 a month, or $425 a month (15% off) for applications received by December 15.

Not sure yet? Email Nitzan about what you are working on and what you would like from the year.

Discussion
Newsletter

Critical Business School, by email: essays, prompts, and new podcast episodes.

More
Essays
Meditate, Then Mediate
Leadership is usually described as something that happens between people. Much of it happens earlier, in the time spent working out what you think. Mediating and meditating are
Essays
How to Play
Play is the most serious thing a creative person does.
Essays
How To, or How Do I?
Value is a combination of utility and aesthetics, a protocol and a way of seeing. Which of your two terms is empty?
Essays
Craft Is a Conversation
Value is utility plus aesthetics. Craft is how the specific enters it.